View Single Post
  #24  
Old 05-15-2016, 03:55 PM
Yardbird's Avatar
Yardbird Yardbird is offline
Senior Member


 
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: South Carolina Lowcountry
Posts: 471
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by ylee View Post
Isolating speakers is something that seems counterintuitive to me. You want the cones (or membrane) - especially bass cones, to be able to reverberate very quickly. This means the cones have to change their direction of travel very quickly. The best way to do that is for the cones to be connected to a rigid cabinet that in turn is solidly anchored to the floor. Hence most speaker companies provide spiked feet for carpet use. I know speaker cabinets are rigid more for avoiding resonance than anything else, but the need for spikes tells me speaker companies have found their products to perform better if they do not move with respect to the floor in any way. Isolation by definition needs to provide the means to blunt the initial impulse of the sound wave either impinging on (or being launched from) your audio component.

In thinking it through with the concepts I'm familiar with, perhaps Stillpoints and other isolation accessories improve the higher frequency tones and retract ever so slightly from the bass tones when used with speakers. The reason I think that is because higher frequency drivers move much faster by definition than lower frequency drivers. Given the relative weights of these drivers with respect to the cabinets in which they're mounted, the isolation of the cabinet from the floor may lessen cabinet resonances for the higher frequency drivers. The bass drivers on the other hand may experience subtle doppler effects that detract from their ability to provide as defined of a tone compared to a cabinet that does not move from the floor - however slight this movement and affect is.

That said, this is all conjecture on my part. I know my fellow audiophiles here have good ears and I believe in the sonic benefits being reported. So that leaves me no choice but to acquire some and hear for myself with my own speakers!
Ylee, I agree with your point about speaker manufacturers' need to control cabinet resonance for the sake of clearest possible sound reproduction, but as far as any doppler effect compromising the deeper bass notes with speakers using isolating footers, I will only address my own results, and can say I heard deeper and better-defined bass from my speakers with the Stillpoints installed. The Stillpoints are designed to dissipate the energy as heat into the device itself, without interacting with the floor. My results led me to the conclusion that when using the factory spikes on the floor system in my home, due to apparent resonances in my floor that evidently added to cabinet motion and compromised my speakers' ability to resolve, I was unable to enjoy the same degree of resolution with my system on factory spikes as on Stillpoints footers. The benefits were not subtle. As audiophiles, we are all interested in optimizing our system's abilities to reproduce sound as accurately as we possibly can. No two rooms or systems are identical, which helps to keep things interesting, and so YMMV, of course. Good luck, and keep us posted! Ted.
__________________

Magico Q3 plus S-Pods, Spectral DMA-500AR, DMC-30SV pre, Esoteric F-03a, Esoteric S-05, Esoteric P02X, N-01XD,
Cybershaft OP21A-D, Roon Nucleus Plus w/S-Booster LPS, Uptone Audio EtherRegen w/ LPS-1.2, MIT Oracle MA-X V2's, Oracle SHD-120 V2, Shunyata Sigma Clock 50’s, Sigma Ethernet’s, Alpha USB-V2, Wireworld Platinum Starlight 7 HDMI's, MIT Oracle Z-III PC's, Z Power Bar Conditioner, Coherence Systems ADD-Powr Sorcer X4, EAU2, Furutech Flux 50 filters, GTX-D rhodium outlets, service sub panel w/ 4-30 amp dedicated circuits, Stillpoints Ultra 6, Ultra 5, Ultra SS, HRS Damping Plates, Cable Isolators, Sony XBR75ZH8.

Last edited by Yardbird; 05-28-2016 at 07:30 PM.
Reply With Quote